Ideology and compliance with health guidelines during the COVID-19 pandemic: A comparative perspective
Social science quarterly
BECHER Michael - Toulouse School of Economics (TSE) (Auteur)
STEGMUELLER Daniel - Duke University (Auteur)
BROUARD Sylvain - Centre de recherches politiques de Sciences Po (Auteur)
KERROUCHE Eric - Centre de recherches politiques de Sciences Po (Auteur)
US : University of Texas Press
Mots clés
COVID-19 Pandemic, Noncompliance, health guidelines, heterogeneity
Objective We measure the prevalence of noncompliance with public health guidelines in the COVID-19 pandemic and examine how it is shaped by political ideology across countries. Methods A list experiment of noncompliance and a multi-item scale of health-related behaviors were embedded in a comparative survey of 11,000 respondents in nine OCED countries. We conduct a statistical analysis of the list experiment capturing degrees of noncompliance with social distancing rules and estimate ideological effect heterogeneity. A semiparametric analysis examines the functional form of the relationship between ideology and the propensity to violate public health guidelines. Results Our analyses reveal substantial heterogeneity between countries. Ideology plays an outsized role in the United States. No association of comparable magnitude is found in the majority of the other countries in our study. In many settings, the impact of ideology on health-related behaviors is nonlinear. Conclusion Our results highlight the importance of taking a comparative perspective. Extrapolating the role of ideology from the United States to other advanced industrialized societies might paint an erroneous picture of the scope of possible nonpharmaceutical interventions. Heterogeneity limits the extent to which policymakers can learn from experiences across borders.